The Fiduciary Rule


View the full report ]

On April 6, 2016, the Department of Labor introduced a long-awaited ruling which requires advisors to put the interests of their clients above their own, adhering to a fiduciary standard of advice.

The Best Interest Contract Exemption (BICE) allows advisors to receive commission and other sales fees while still complying with the fiduciary standard. All of which means commission stays, but how easy this will be for advisors to implement is uncertain.

The rigidness of the BICE guidelines has eased significantly since conception. Originally, the exemption limited the scope of permissible assets to recommend (non-traded REITs were not permitted for example) and required extensive disclosure on fees and costs. The implementation period of the rule has also changed, with the full compliance deadline extended one year until January 1, 2018.

These developments should ease some of the concerns over the regulatory costs of the rule but will not fully eliminate them. The financial industry has warned the cost of the rule will make advice more expensive and that the financial burden will fall upon consumers — as was the case when similar regulation was introduced in other countries.
Opponents of the rule argue smaller clients will be faced with unaffordable fees, thereby limiting the access that middle-class investors have to advice. Previous CoreData analysis revealed that about seven in ten advisors in the UK said the Retail Distribution Review (RDR) had made it more challenging to work with low balance clients. To combat this, a third said they would consider adding an execution-only service for low balance clients.

Indeed, similar regulation in the UK and South Africa has steered middle-class investors away from advice. Previous CoreData studies show about one in five advisors in the UK and one in four in South Africa reported a decrease in the number of clients they advise. Regulation has also impacted investment products. About four in ten advisors in the UK and South Africa said regulation had influenced the investment products they advise on.

Advisory firms in the US are expected to hire new staff to help implement the rule. This would mirror the example of advisors in the UK and South Africa who reported taking on new staff (and the associated costs) to help comply with regulation. About one in five in the UK and South Africa cited regulation as reason for hiring new people.

Under the new rules, the BICE heightens brokers’ liability risk. This impacts the cost-benefit analysis of the commission model. If advisors want to continue earning commission, they must sign a legally binding contract with clients detailing their fiduciary responsibilities, revealing any potential conflicts of interest and stating firm policies to mitigate conflicts of interest. While the contract aims to hold advisors accountable, the cost of implementation is high.

If advisors are to demonstrate the advice they give is in the best interest of clients, they will have to develop a solid understanding of client needs in order to justify their recommendations. Many think this will result in advisors spending more time meeting clients. This certainly holds true for the UK, where four in ten said they met with clients more following regulatory change.

Even though commission-based advice is still allowed under the new US rule, many firms with revenues heavily derived from commission will look at redressing the balance between upfront fees and commission. Although the DOL rule has evolved into a more diluted version of the original proposal, advisors should nevertheless reconsider their compensation policies for the long-term in light of increased regulation and scrutiny of the industry.

How President-elect Donald Trump will approach the fiduciary rule remains uncertain. Before the election, the rule was set to progress forward.


  1. Pingback:
  2. Pingback: cheap viagra
  3. Pingback: Viagra 25mg uk
  4. Pingback: avapro 300mg otc
  5. Pingback: ceclor for sale
  6. Pingback: celexa nz
  7. Pingback: cipro purchase
  8. Pingback: claritin pills
  9. Pingback: hollywood casino
  10. Pingback: casino
  11. Pingback: online casinos
  12. Pingback: gambling games
  13. Pingback: best car insurance
  14. Pingback: aarp car insurance
  15. Pingback: payday loans ohio
  16. Pingback: payday lenders
  17. Pingback: homework research
  18. Pingback: cleocin tablets
  19. Pingback: generic cialis
  20. Pingback: crestor coupon
  21. Pingback: phd by thesis only
  22. Pingback: ddavp 0.1mg cheap
  23. Pingback: depakote cost
  24. Pingback: differin 15g price
  25. Pingback: elavil 25 mg usa
  26. Pingback: cheapest flomax
  27. Pingback: hyzaar for sale
  28. Pingback: buy cialis online
  29. Pingback: imdur 40 mg tablet
  30. Pingback: imitrex uk
  31. Pingback: home
  32. Pingback: imuran uk
  33. Pingback: indocin australia
  34. Pingback: lopid 300 mg nz
  35. Pingback: luvox for sale
  36. Pingback: meclizine nz
  37. Pingback: buy periactin 4 mg
  38. Pingback: viagra
  39. Pingback: phenergan tablets
  40. Pingback: prevacid generic
  41. Pingback: cheap reglan 10 mg
  42. Pingback: risperdal cost
  43. Pingback: buy robaxin 500mg
  44. Pingback: cost of seroquel
  45. Pingback: tenormin nz
  46. Pingback: thorazine cheap
  47. Pingback: toprol 50mg cheap
  48. Pingback: tricor cheap
  49. Pingback: voltaren purchase
  50. Pingback: cost of wellbutrin
  51. Pingback: zanaflex 4mg nz
  52. Pingback: this post
  53. Pingback: buy zocor
  54. Pingback: zyloprim tablets
  55. Pingback: order zyprexa
  56. Pingback: zyvox generic
  57. Pingback: furosemide tablet
  58. Pingback: leflunomide coupon
  59. Pingback: atomoxetine uk
  60. Pingback: buspirone purchase
  61. Pingback: carvedilolmg pills
  62. Pingback: fluconazole nz
  63. Pingback: cheap oxybutynin
  64. Pingback: buy azithromycin
  65. Pingback: buy erythromycin
  66. Pingback: estradiol price
  67. Pingback: darkijku
  68. Pingback: loperamide canada
  69. Pingback: viagra
  70. Pingback: gemfibrozil online
  71. Pingback: cost of metoprolol
  72. Pingback: clotrimazole pills
  73. Pingback: doxycycline 300 mg
  74. Pingback: diflucan valtrex
  75. Pingback: essay help
  76. Pingback: thesis template
  77. Pingback: best dissertations
  78. Pingback: paxil dose
  79. Pingback: plaquenil msds
  80. Pingback: canada viagra
  81. Pingback: dapoxetine cialis
  82. Pingback: cialis onset
  83. Pingback:
  84. Pingback: augmentin liquid
  85. Pingback: augmentin liquid
  86. Pingback: is dapoxetine otc
  87. Pingback: sertraline anxiety
  88. Pingback: buy sildenafil
  89. Pingback: viagra online
  90. Pingback: discount viagra
  91. Pingback: cialis tab 10mg
  92. Pingback: sildenafil
  93. Pingback: buy generic viagra
  94. Pingback: sildenafil viagra

Comments are closed.